Adding a pool to your backyard is an exciting decision—but choosing between an inground or above ground pool can feel like a major crossroads. Each option comes with its own advantages, limitations, costs, and considerations. If you’re trying to decide which type of pool is right for your home, this guide will help break down the key differences to support your decision-making process.
Initial Installation Costs
Cost is one of the biggest factors homeowners weigh when choosing a pool. Above ground pools are significantly more affordable upfront. Many can be purchased and installed for between $3,000 and $10,000, depending on size and features. In contrast, inground pools often start around $35,000 and can easily exceed $75,000 with custom materials, landscaping, and hardscaping.
However, it’s important to consider what you’re paying for. Inground pools are permanent structures that often include superior materials, design flexibility, and long-term value. Above ground pools are usually made of less durable materials and may need to be replaced after 7–15 years, depending on maintenance and quality.
Design and Aesthetic Appeal
If your goal is to create a backyard oasis or boost your home’s visual appeal, an inground pool offers more customization. You can choose from a wide range of shapes, depths, finishes, lighting, and landscaping. Features like waterfalls, tanning ledges, and integrated spas are commonly added to inground designs.
Above ground pools are typically limited to round or oval shapes and standard heights. While some modern models come with attractive finishes and decks, they rarely offer the sleek integration into a landscape that an inground pool can. That said, you can still achieve a polished look with above ground pools by investing in a wraparound deck, stone veneer skirting, and thoughtful landscaping.
Installation Timeline
In terms of speed, above ground pools win hands down. Many models can be installed in a single weekend with a professional crew—or even as a DIY project if you’re handy. Inground pools, by contrast, often take several weeks to complete due to excavation, permitting, plumbing, electrical work, and final finishing touches.
If you’re looking for quick summer enjoyment or a last-minute backyard upgrade, an above ground pool may be the faster solution. For long-term plans, however, the investment in an inground pool might be worth the wait.
Durability and Maintenance
Inground pools, particularly those built with concrete or gunite, are long-lasting structures that can serve your home for decades with proper care. Fiberglass and vinyl-lined options offer different lifespans and maintenance needs. Above ground pools, while more affordable initially, are more vulnerable to weather damage, punctures, and general wear and tear.
Both types of pools require routine maintenance such as cleaning, reverse osmosis for swimming pool water, chemical balancing, and occasional repairs. Inground pools tend to have more sophisticated filtration and automation systems, which can make upkeep easier if managed properly. Above ground models may have more basic setups but are often simpler to access for repairs.
Safety Considerations
Safety is a top priority for any pool owner, especially for households with young children or pets. Above ground pools are generally considered safer due to their elevated structure, which makes it harder for children to fall in accidentally. Adding a secure ladder or gate system enhances protection.
Inground pools require more comprehensive safety solutions, such as fences, pool covers, and alarms. Many municipalities require these features by law, and some HOAs may have their own regulations. Regardless of which pool you choose, investing in strong safety measures is essential.
Property Value and Long-Term ROI
When it comes to increasing your home’s resale value, inground pools have the edge. A well-maintained inground pool can add to the appeal of your home—especially in warmer climates where swimming pools are a high priority for buyers. Above ground pools, however, are often considered temporary structures and may not contribute positively to your home’s value.
That said, the value of any pool will depend on your neighborhood, climate, and how well it complements your home. A thoughtfully installed above ground pool with a deck and landscaping may still be a strong selling point in some markets. Keep in mind that investing in reverse osmosis for swimming pool water is another worthy way to enhance your property value!
Space and Location
Inground pools typically require more yard space and more substantial planning for grading, drainage, and underground utilities. If your backyard is large, flat, and sunny, you may have plenty of flexibility for an inground build. Smaller or sloped yards may pose challenges—but creative pool builders can often find innovative solutions.
Above ground pools are more flexible when it comes to space. They can often be placed in tighter or more irregular areas and removed or relocated more easily if needed. For homeowners with limited space or those planning on future renovations, this can be a major advantage.
Climate and Seasonal Use
In colder regions, pools must be winterized and closed for several months. Above ground pools are typically easier to drain and cover during the off-season. Inground pools require more extensive winterization but may have more robust heating options to extend your swimming season.
In warmer climates, inground pools tend to provide year-round enjoyment, making them a better investment for daily use. Heated above ground pools can help stretch your season, but often at a higher energy cost.
Which Pool Is Right for You?
Still not sure which to choose? Here are a few questions to ask yourself:
- What’s your budget? If cost is a concern, an above ground pool is a great way to enjoy swimming without a major investment.
- Are you looking for a long-term feature or a seasonal addition? Inground pools are permanent, while above ground models are more temporary.
- Do you want to enhance your home’s aesthetics? Inground pools offer greater design possibilities and curb appeal.
- How much space do you have? Small or uneven yards might be better suited to above ground installations.
- Are you concerned with safety? Both pools can be safe, but above ground pools may offer an extra layer of natural security.
Answering these questions can help guide your decision based on your home, budget, and goals.
Choosing between an inground and above ground pool doesn’t come down to which one is better—it comes down to which one is right for your specific lifestyle and home. If you’re looking for a quick, budget-friendly way to cool off during the summer, an above ground pool may be the perfect choice. If you’re aiming to create a luxurious, permanent backyard retreat, an inground pool might be worth the investment. Whichever direction you choose, working with a reputable pool contractor can help bring your vision to life safely and efficiently. From design to installation and maintenance, professional support ensures your pool will be an asset you’ll enjoy for years to come.
